Cooking With Tasha Tudor: Becky’s Birthday Cake with Cocoa Frosting

   Good morning, friends! Here we are another Tuesday, and another Cooking with Tasha Tudor post! This past week was rather festive for me, as Sunday was my birthday! So, of course, I had birthday cake on the brain 🙂 Audrey and I got into the kitchen then to make, of course, “Becky’s Birthday Cake” as featured in the beautiful Tasha Tudor book, “Becky’s Birthday.” Here’s Audrey getting to work:

   Now— let me preface this-— I had high hopes for this cake! But there was a ton going on this week in my life, and perhaps I was a little distracted. There were also some things in this deceptively simple recipe that I wasn’t used to doing for a cake (like whipped egg whites in the batter) and the frosting– which seemed so very simple on paper— appears to also be something that takes some practice to get right.

   So the end result cake was…..well, when I saw it on the cake platter, I laughed until I had tears in my eyes. I’m not even gonna show it because I dont want it to be the representation of Tasha’s beloved cake on the internet, haha. Let’s just say…. “Nailed it!” 😉

   BUT….it looked fine cut into pieces and the icing was tasty with a dash of coffee in it. If you make the cocoa icing I suggest adding the liquids verrrry slowly because it can go from thick to runny very quickly. Tread with caution!

   I think I’ll try this recipe again another time to see if I can get it right. It is, evidently, not something to do when your brain is slightly addled from a week full of out of the ordinary things to do!

   But in Becky’s Birthday, which is a lovely book, the cake turns out so lovely it gets floated down a creek in its own raft! By candlelight! I’m sure in Tasha’s hand, it was amazing! Let’s take a peek at the book….

   Several years ago I was contacted by a woman dissolving a relative’s estate, and she had several Tasha Tudor books she wanted to find good homes for— and some of them were signed. She let me know her list of books she had and kindly let me choose which I’d like to buy, and one of the books I purchased from her was this pristine copy of “Becky’s Birthday,” complete with Tasha Tudor’s autograph on the inside page! Its a treasure to me. Sweet too, because when she signed this book in 1992, I was 10 going on 11. Just about Becky’s age in the story!

    The illustrations in this book are gorgeous, and as a total Tasha Tudor nerd, there are some characters in the story that I can pick out from Tasha’s life. Look at that drawing of Becky’s father— it is basically a portrait of Tasha’s own father, Starling Burgess. Pop over here to see a photo and you’ll totally see it too.

   I’m also wondering if the character of the mother in the story is a likeness of Tasha’s friend Nell Dorr, although on that one I’m not as sure about. All the children in the book, of course, bare a likeness to Tasha’s own children, which is sweet. I know for me, I tend to draw children and babies that look suspiciously like my own!

 And, ah! There it is! Becky’s birthday cake! In this photo I’m pretty sure the cake is frosted with the white boiled frosting that Tasha also lists in her cookbook (all these recipes can be found in the Tasha Tudor cookbook). It looks beautiful in the illustration, and makes me want to give it another go!

   Because, well, dear reader, sometimes its hit-or-miss in the kitchen! Just as it is in the garden, or at the painting table 🙂 if you’ve made the Becky’s Birthday Cake, I’d love to hear about it and how it turned out, and if you have any tips for me for next time! I feel like I’ve seen other’s make it and its come out fantastically.

   Well, that is it for today. What shall I cook for next week? Time to start looking—
Take Joy!~

4 thoughts on “Cooking With Tasha Tudor: Becky’s Birthday Cake with Cocoa Frosting

  1. Well, that slice of cake looked delicious despite the difficulties of the recipe! Baking is hard for me because it does take a level of expertise and finesse that I just don't have. The older and more traditional recipes are also harder to make come out right. We are so spoiled these days with wonderful and successful box mixes for many cakes. The pictures from Becky's BIrthday are just so sweet! It is also fascinating to learn the connections that you see of where Tasha incorporated her own story into her books.


  2. How delightful that you were able to buy a signed book!!!! And I'm sure the lady was very happy, to know it would have a loving home, with you.Sometimes we just have to accept, that something we bake, may not look \”purrrrrfect.\” And just concentrate on how delicious it tastes.Belated Happy Birthday!Autumn hugs,A 'Nana'✨🍁🎃🍁✨


  3. Yes, that is very true! If you never try something new, then you only do a few things in life…sometimes you gotta go out on a limb! Thanks so much for the birthday wishes, I appreciate it!~


  4. Yes! I can always appreciate modern easy short cuts, for sure! But do love the experience of doing it the old fashioned way. Love looking at the little details of Tasha's work, she is such a wonderful craftsman of cozy scenes!


Leave a Reply to wisps of words Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s